Dutch was there for the money, same as Micah. He then listened to John and realised Micah had to die because he was a cunt. So he kills Micah. John lets him walk because of their prior connection & perhaps believing that the "old Dutch" was back. Plus he (and even Sadie) blamed Micah moreso than Dutch for everything that happened. So none of the men can go into Blackwater because they all have prices on their heads, but to me the obvious solution to that is to send one of the women to go and retrieve the money. Since the women don't fight, they go unnoticed by the law, evidenced by the fact most of them are able to enjoy a peaceful life in the epilogue. RDR2 World Map. Red Dead Online Map. Increases the value of looted money by 10% $22.75 Fox Claw Trinket: Legendary Fox Claw Increases Eagle Eye duration by five seconds $23.50 After Arthur’s death, John has to start from scratch. But there’s a way to get Arthur’s money back. Make sure you finished the mission: ‘My Last Boy’ (the death of Eagle Flies). Go to the Aberdeen Pig Farm as Arthur, with the not at all creepy incestuous siblings. Accept the drink, (or the food sample if it’s your second visit) and Red Dead Redemption 2. I Found The Stash In Blackwater! Ok, Chapter 3 when you move to Lemoyne camp, first mission where you go fishing with Dutch and end up chasing the train with deputy sheriff, if you go finishing at the end of the mission, Dutch tells you his mother is buried in Blackwater, that his uncle told him a while back. Blessed are the Peacemakers is a mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Dutch's gang attempts to negotiate peace with O'Discrolls. You are left to deal with the aftermath. Blessed are the Peacemakers is one of the main missions available in Red Dead Redemption 2. This is a rather interesting mission - Arthur participates in a peaceful conversation Is Dutch money still in a cave? If you chose the honorable option, Dutch’s chest will remain in Beaver Hollow. If you chose the honorable option, Dutch’s chest will remain in Beaver Hollow. As a matter of fact, I discovered this recently, but if you returned to Beaver Hollow as John, Dutch’s chest would still be under the wagon as well. Arthur agree with Dutch on the planning every time because he knows he's not the thinker. Micah knows he's not smarter than Dutch and Dutch knows he's the smartest in the gang. Micah agreeing with Dutch and Arthur not being able to reason soundly just brought further this idea of "doubting". To sum it up. hyfm.